English Este artigo foi escrito originalmente em inglês.
Português Ler em Português
Clique 2x para traduzir
(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

President Trump said in a recent CBS 60 Minutes interview (accessible here): “I sat in the Oval Office, first term, and a little bit second term, meeting with Air Force pilots that are really good, solid people… And they’ve told me things that are very strange, in certain cases. They said, ‘Yes, there’s something going on out there.’ Because they’re flying an F-22, which is the best there is, the fastest […] And something goes by them at three times their speed, and it’s round. It’s not aerodynamic.”

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

These reports about spherical objects moving faster than sound without visible signs of propulsion are puzzling. Such objects are anomalous for two reasons.

First, what propels these objects? Rockets or fighter jets speed up forward because they eject matter backwards. This is a manifestation of the conservation of momentum, namely the product of mass times velocity. The gas coming out of the exhaust moves backwards, pushing the fighter jet forward. If an ice skater at rest throws a bowling ball one way, their body will be pushed in the opposite direction with a momentum equal to that of the ball. If momentum conservation applies to the reported spherical objects, the pilots should have witnessed a hot plume of exhaust gas coming out of the rear end of these objects, with a non-spherical heat signature in infrared images.

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

Second, why is the shape of these supersonic objects spherical rather than aerodynamic? An object moving faster than sound encounters a strong drag force which scales with its speed squared times its frontal surface area. Supersonic aircraft like the B-1B Lancer are shaped like a needle and sweep their wings backward to reduce their surface drag relative to the oncoming supersonic airflow. A spherical shape is not optimal for reducing drag. The only context where spherical objects appear naturally are balloons, but these are carried by winds and never exceed 40% of the speed of sound.

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

Is there a caveat to these constraints? Can exotic alien technology produce spherical objects that speed up rather than slow down as a result of their friction on air without internal propulsion?

The answer is: “Yes”. One such possibility came to my mind before my morning jog at sunrise. We are used to objects with a positive mass. They obey Newton’s law of inertia, where the acceleration of an object — which is the rate by which its velocity changes (a) equals the ratio between the force applied to it (F) and its mass (M):

a=F/m.

As a result, the friction force on air (F<0) slows down the motion of spherical objects (a<0) with a positive mass (m>0).

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

But what if a spherical object has a negative inertial mass (m<0)? In that case, the friction force (F<0) would speed up the object (a>0). Could that explain the anomalous motion and shape of the objects reported by the pilots and President Trump?

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

The problem with such a scenario is that it leads to a runaway motion, in which the spherical object will continue to speed up until it reaches the speed of light. One way to moderate the runaway behavior is to accompany the negative mass with a positive mass payload. A system with a nearly zero total mass (m=0) is easy to move around with an extremely weak propulsion system, because a=F/m yields a large a for a small m. Hence, a system with a controllable small residual mass can either speed up or slow down depending on the sign of its tiny mass.

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

However, there is no free lunch. Our current, albeit limited, understanding of quantum field theory and causality forbid the existence of matter with a negative mass. Gravitationally, such matter would accelerate the passage of time near it, opposite to the familiar “Shapiro time delay” — named after my Harvard colleague, Irwin Shapiro. As a result, one can arrange a setup by which a ray of light will pass near negative-mass objects which move at relativistic speeds, and return to its starting point before its departure time. A time machine violates causality and could lead to logical inconsistencies, whereby children can prevent their parents from conceiving them. Moreover, even in relativistic quantum field theory without gravity, it is impossible to define free causal quantum fields with negative masses.

In 1957, the physicist Herman Bondi published a paper here which showed that a pair of positive and negative mass particles will follow runaway motion without an external force, as a result of their gravitational interaction. When placed near each other, the negative mass pushes the positive mass away. At the same time, the positive mass pulls the negative mass toward it, causing the negative mass to chase the positive mass. If both masses have the exact same magnitude (+m and -m), both objects accelerate at the exact same rate in the same direction. They maintain a constant distance from one another while speeding up. At first glance, runaway motion looks like a perpetual motion machine that creates energy and momentum out of nothing. However, Bondi’s solution maintains energy and momentum conservation, because the negative mass carries a negative energy and a negative momentum that exactly balances the positive values of the positive mass.

In summary, matter with negative mass leads to runaway motion and violates causality based on our current understanding of gravity and quantum mechanics. But since we do not yet have a predictive theory of quantum gravity, perhaps we should remain open minded to its existence.

Two months ago, I published a paper here in collaboration with the brilliant student Oem Trivedi, where we studied the gravitational wave signature of objects with a negative mass.

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

Does the Universe contain negative-mass objects?

Such objects may be an exotic, unrecognized relic of the Big Bang or they may have been produced in the laboratories of alien quantum-gravity engineers. If they fly through the Earth’s atmosphere, the pilots who discovered them first should get the Nobel Prize in experimental physics.

(Image credit: Greg Wyatt)

In this essay, I featured nine amazingly beautiful watercolors from a series created and sent to me by the celebrated artist, Greg Wyatt.

Authorized publication by Dr.Avi Loeb

Autor: Dr.Avi Loeb

Chair of the UAP Science Advisory Council to the White House, Pentagon, FBI and intelligence agencies, director of the Galileo Project, founding director of Harvard University’s — Black Hole Initiative, former director of the Institute for Theory and Computation at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, and the former chair of the astronomy department at Harvard University (2011–2020). He is a former member of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology and a former chair of the Board on Physics and Astronomy of the National Academies.

Partilhar:
Partilhar traduzido: EN ES

English Español